Taste The Best Key Lime Pie In Florida On This Exciting Trail

Is there anything more iconic than key lime pie in Florida? We think not. It’s sooo tarty and tasty, and it was created right here in our very own Florida Keys. Drive along the Overseas Highway to take this Florida Key Lime Pie Trail, which includes everything from traditional pie to some interesting, creative takes on our very own Florida dessert.

The 113-mile-long Overseas Highway runs from Key West to Key Largo and is one of the most beautiful (and delicious) drives in the country.

Mark Kieffer/flickr

As you travel in search of the best key lime pie in Florida, thankfully there are plenty of these juicy fruits throughout the state.

Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen/Facebook Key limes are different than regular limes. They’re much more tart, and their juice is yellow. These tasty little limes grow very well in the Florida Keys, and many folks have a Key lime bush in their yard. But enough about the fruit! Let’s get to where to find the pie!

Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen, Key Largo

Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen/Facebook

Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen/Facebook The Key lime pie at Mrs. Mac’s is dense and tart. This pie is made with a recipe that’s over 30 years old. Visit them at 99336 Overseas Hwy., Key Largo. To learn more, check out the official website for Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen.

Sweet Savannah’s Bake Shop & Ice Cream Cafe, Marathon

Sweet Savannah’s Bake Shop & Ice Cream Cafe/Facebook

Sweet Savannah’s Bake Shop & Ice Cream Cafe/Facebook This adorable little bake shop/ice cream parlor offers up a different twist on Key lime pie - a cupcake version! Sweet Savannah’s offers up a sweet vanilla cupcake with a Key lime curd. The Key lime buttercream icing gives it a tangy-sweet topping. You’ll find this tasty sweets shop at 8919 Overseas Hwy., Marathon. Visit the official website for Sweet Savannah’s Bake Shop to learn more.

Kermit’s Key Lime West Key Lime Shoppe, Key West

Kermit’s Key Lime West Key Lime Shoppe/Facebook

Kristy L/Yelp This fun, quirky shop offers all things Key lime - including, of course, Kermit’s delectable Key lime pie. In addition to slices of the delicious pie, the shop offers a frozen slice, dipped in chocolate and served on a stick. Owner Kermit Carpenter is usually on premises to say hello! Taste these magnificent treats at 200 Elizabeth St, # A, Key West. To learn more, visit the official website for Kermit’s Key Lime Shoppe in Florida.

This Florida Key Lime Pie Trail was created by WestJet Magazine, and of course it just includes the highlights. What’s your favorite place to get key lime pie in Florida? Share your thoughts with us in the comments below!

Mark Kieffer/flickr

Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen/Facebook

Key limes are different than regular limes. They’re much more tart, and their juice is yellow. These tasty little limes grow very well in the Florida Keys, and many folks have a Key lime bush in their yard. But enough about the fruit! Let’s get to where to find the pie!

The Key lime pie at Mrs. Mac’s is dense and tart. This pie is made with a recipe that’s over 30 years old. Visit them at 99336 Overseas Hwy., Key Largo. To learn more, check out the official website for Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen.

Sweet Savannah’s Bake Shop & Ice Cream Cafe/Facebook

This adorable little bake shop/ice cream parlor offers up a different twist on Key lime pie - a cupcake version! Sweet Savannah’s offers up a sweet vanilla cupcake with a Key lime curd. The Key lime buttercream icing gives it a tangy-sweet topping. You’ll find this tasty sweets shop at 8919 Overseas Hwy., Marathon. Visit the official website for Sweet Savannah’s Bake Shop to learn more.

Kermit’s Key Lime West Key Lime Shoppe/Facebook

Kristy L/Yelp

This fun, quirky shop offers all things Key lime - including, of course, Kermit’s delectable Key lime pie. In addition to slices of the delicious pie, the shop offers a frozen slice, dipped in chocolate and served on a stick. Owner Kermit Carpenter is usually on premises to say hello! Taste these magnificent treats at 200 Elizabeth St, # A, Key West. To learn more, visit the official website for Kermit’s Key Lime Shoppe in Florida.

Ready for more Florida dining? Check out these 10 Florida Restaurants That Are Hard To Find But Worth The Search.

OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.

Address: 99336 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037, USAAddress: 8919 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050, USAAddress: 200 Elizabeth St, Key West, FL 33040, USA

The OIYS Visitor Center

key lime pie in Florida August 31, 2020 Elisa Regulski What are the best places to get desserts in Florida? Got a mighty sweet tooth? You’re in luck! There are so many fabulous places to get desserts in Florida. If it’s ice cream you’re after, visit Coney’s Italian Ice and Creamery in Eustis. This retro eatery will whisk you back to a simpler time. You’ll fall in love with their cold and creamy creations. If you’re craving a slice of homemade pie, head over to Yoder’s Restaurant & Amish Village in Sarasota. There is something so comforting about these fruit pies. These mouthwatering sweets will make you feel warm and fuzzy inside. If you still haven’t satisfied your sweet tooth, check out these unique desserts in Florida. What are the most famous restaurants in Florida? Blue Heaven, located in Key West, is one of the most famous restaurants in Florida. This gorgeous little cafe serves a wide variety of tasty meals, but they’re most known for their epic key lime pie. This giant dessert is served with mile-high meringue, and each bite is pure bliss. For something a bit different, visit Columbia Restaurant. This scrumptious Spanish eatery is actually the oldest restaurant in Florida! Everyone in the Sunshine State should visit at least once. What kind of food is Florida known for? When most people think about food in Florida, their mind goes to key lime pie. But this is only the beginning! In addition to this tart and tangy treat, The Sunshine State is known for its epic seafood selections. From local oysters to fresh stone crab, we can do it all! And nothing beats enjoying a scrumptious meal along one of our pristine sandy beaches. We really know how to dine in Florida! It’s easy to see why folks here are always so laid back and carefree.

The OIYS Visitor Center

key lime pie in Florida

August 31, 2020

Elisa Regulski

What are the best places to get desserts in Florida? Got a mighty sweet tooth? You’re in luck! There are so many fabulous places to get desserts in Florida. If it’s ice cream you’re after, visit Coney’s Italian Ice and Creamery in Eustis. This retro eatery will whisk you back to a simpler time. You’ll fall in love with their cold and creamy creations. If you’re craving a slice of homemade pie, head over to Yoder’s Restaurant & Amish Village in Sarasota. There is something so comforting about these fruit pies. These mouthwatering sweets will make you feel warm and fuzzy inside. If you still haven’t satisfied your sweet tooth, check out these unique desserts in Florida. What are the most famous restaurants in Florida? Blue Heaven, located in Key West, is one of the most famous restaurants in Florida. This gorgeous little cafe serves a wide variety of tasty meals, but they’re most known for their epic key lime pie. This giant dessert is served with mile-high meringue, and each bite is pure bliss. For something a bit different, visit Columbia Restaurant. This scrumptious Spanish eatery is actually the oldest restaurant in Florida! Everyone in the Sunshine State should visit at least once. What kind of food is Florida known for? When most people think about food in Florida, their mind goes to key lime pie. But this is only the beginning! In addition to this tart and tangy treat, The Sunshine State is known for its epic seafood selections. From local oysters to fresh stone crab, we can do it all! And nothing beats enjoying a scrumptious meal along one of our pristine sandy beaches. We really know how to dine in Florida! It’s easy to see why folks here are always so laid back and carefree.

The OIYS Visitor Center

Got a mighty sweet tooth? You’re in luck! There are so many fabulous places to get desserts in Florida. If it’s ice cream you’re after, visit Coney’s Italian Ice and Creamery in Eustis. This retro eatery will whisk you back to a simpler time. You’ll fall in love with their cold and creamy creations. If you’re craving a slice of homemade pie, head over to Yoder’s Restaurant & Amish Village in Sarasota. There is something so comforting about these fruit pies. These mouthwatering sweets will make you feel warm and fuzzy inside. If you still haven’t satisfied your sweet tooth, check out these unique desserts in Florida.

What are the most famous restaurants in Florida?

Blue Heaven, located in Key West, is one of the most famous restaurants in Florida. This gorgeous little cafe serves a wide variety of tasty meals, but they’re most known for their epic key lime pie. This giant dessert is served with mile-high meringue, and each bite is pure bliss. For something a bit different, visit Columbia Restaurant. This scrumptious Spanish eatery is actually the oldest restaurant in Florida! Everyone in the Sunshine State should visit at least once.

What kind of food is Florida known for?

When most people think about food in Florida, their mind goes to key lime pie. But this is only the beginning! In addition to this tart and tangy treat, The Sunshine State is known for its epic seafood selections. From local oysters to fresh stone crab, we can do it all! And nothing beats enjoying a scrumptious meal along one of our pristine sandy beaches. We really know how to dine in Florida! It’s easy to see why folks here are always so laid back and carefree.