If you haven’t lived in Amherst, there’s a good chance you’ve never heard of Sibie’s Pizza. This local pizza shop is a hole in the wall that’s unbeknownst to most, but it’s a beloved restaurant for those who live in the area. Next time you’re near Amherst, it’s worth stopping at Sibie’s Pizza for a truly fresh pie. With dough that’s made fresh daily, many unique toppings, and vegan and gluten-free options for your friends with food sensitivities, it doesn’t get better than this. If you’re not in the mood for pizza, they also have awesome subs and wings. When you want to support a family-owned business while indulging on some incredible pizza, head to the hidden gem that is Sibie’s Pizza in Amherst and you won’t regret it.
Welcome to Sibie’s Pizza!
Google Maps
This tiny hole in the wall pizza spot is located in Amherst, and has become a local favorite throughout the years. This spot is half Italian, half Greek inspired, making for a wholly unforgettable pie.
Sibie’s Pizza/Facebook
Not only is this the best pizza place in Amherst, it’s also the oldest that’s still operated by its original owners. Sibie’s is a family-owned establishment, and owner George Duranti can still be found in the kitchen.
Sibie’s Pizza/Google Local
You won’t find pizza any fresher than this. Every morning, the dough and sauce are made fresh, and even ingredients such as the sausage are handmade.
management/TripAdvisor
Sibie’s pizza is a family recipe, but you can always customize the toppings. You’ll find tons of unique creations from chicken taco pizza to a Mediterranean blend.
management/TripAdvisor
If you’re not in the mood for pizza, Sibie’s is also known for its subs. They have a large menu featuring subs, wings, and salads, which are also fresh as can be.
Sibie’s Pizza/Google Local
For those with food sensitivities, Sibie’s is the best spot in the area for a vegan or gluten-free pizza. The options are truly endless.
Sibie’s Pizza/Facebook
While there are plenty of pizza spots in the Bay State, Sibie’s Pizza in Amherst is a family-owned hidden gem worth seeking out.
management/TripAdvisor For more information on Sibie’s Pizza, you can visit their website right here.
Have you ever been to Sibie’s Pizza? Do you think they have the freshest pizza in Amherst? We’d love to hear your thoughts and experiences in the comments!
Google Maps
Sibie’s Pizza/Facebook
Sibie’s Pizza/Google Local
management/TripAdvisor
For more information on Sibie’s Pizza, you can visit their website right here.
Is there another great local business we should know about? You can use our form to nominate a business, and they may be featured in an upcoming article!
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
Address: 481 West St, Amherst, MA 01002, USA
