A quick search for “pies near me” will reveal that Connecticut has a number of pie spots, especially if you include pizza, but where are the best places for pie around? Well if you’re talking scrumptious dessert pies like apple or blueberry we have the answer. However you order, from warm to cold, with or without the ice cream, these pies will have your sweet tooth going crazy! Sample the selection from across the state and tell us which one is your favorite.
You can check out the best places for pie below:
- Sixpence Pie Company
Joe K./Yelp 26 North Main Street, Southington, CT 06489
Sixpence Pie Company/Facebook Please note, Sixpence Pie Company is no longer in business. These folks make the perfect buttery, flaky crust. But even better, they are more about filling than anything else so you’re getting a lot of fruit! Their minis are the perfect portion and you don’t have to share.
- Elmwood Pastry Shop
Google Maps 1136 New Britain Avenue, West Hartford, CT 06110
Elmwood Pastry Shop/Facebook This pecan pie looks as though it were literally made out of gold. But guess what? It tastes even better than it looks. This family owned business has been cranking out pies since 1948 so they’re experts.
- Cutie Pies
Krista C./Yelp 131 Main Street, Thomaston, CT 06787
Krista C./Yelp Here’s an apple, banana cream, and chocolate cream pie just waiting to be savored. This place prides itself on making affordable pies without sacrificing on flavor. Visit often to sample their seasonal options.
- Soleil & Suns
Google Maps 35 CT-171, Woodstock, CT 06281
Soleil & Suns Bakery LLC/Facebook Strawberry Rhubarb anyone? This full service bakery actually serves up fresh baked everything, so you can’t go wrong with a visit. Featured in Connecticut Magazine they’re a must try.
- American Pie Company
James B./Yelp 29 Route 37 Center, Sherman, CT 06784
Cesar L./Yelp It’s so hard to choose just one of these scrumptious pies. Lucky for us, you can order by the slice because you’ll definitely want to try every one.
- The Pantry
Anne R./Yelp 1580 Post Road, Fairfield, CT 06824
Amy T./Yelp Not only does this place make all the classic pie flavors that you love, but they are also using cannoli in new and different ways, including in pies, tarts and cakes. Come get your little taste of Italy right here in Connecticut.
- Blackberry River Baking Co.
Blackberry River Baking Co/Facebook 18 Main Street, Canaan, CT 06018
Blackberry River Baking Co/Facebook Apple pies just like grandma used to make. For folks who like a crispier crust or are seeking the perfect crumble, this is the place to go. Every pie is carefully created and baked with love.
- Oronoque Farms
Google Maps 188 Leavenworth Road, Shelton, CT 06484
Oronoque Farms Gift & Bakery/Facebook Baked to perfection, this is a great place to pick up a classic apple or a Boston Cream for a summer picnic. The braided crust is proof of the care these chefs put in to baking each pie. These pair perfectly with ice cream and are a long time fan favorite.
- Bishop’s Orchards
Bishop’s Orchards Farm Market/Facebook 1355 Boston Post Road, Guilford, CT 06437
Bishop’s Orchards Farm Market/Facebook All the fruit and cream flavors you could ever dream of, baked fresh daily and packed up for your convenience. These pies are the perfect end to an orchard visit and are guaranteed to leave your stomach (and heart) full.
- Mothership Bakery
Mothership Bakery & Cafe/Facebook 44 Old Ridgebury Rd, Danbury, CT 06810
Mothership Bakery & Cafe/Facebook This mixed berry pie is literally begging for you to eat it. And why wouldn’t you? The golden crust crumbles and then melts in your mouth and the filling is oh so sweet.
- Granny’s Pie Factory
Granny’s Pie Factory/Facebook 103 School St, East Hartford, CT 06108
Granny’s Pie Factory/Facebook The delicious is hiding in the details! This place is known for its perfect outward experience, making it the go to place for pies that are both beautiful and delectable. They pride themselves on making something the whole family can enjoy together and folks just can’t get enough.
- Michele’s Pies
Jose C./Yelp 666 Main Avenue, Norwalk, CT 06851
Michele’s Pies/Facebook This little shop is famous for its decadent twist on classics, like this caramel crumble covered apple. These pies have won awards in many a competition and every one is baked with love. But don’t take my word for it. Taste these pies for yourself!
These may be the best places for pie, but where do you go to snag a creamy frozen treat? Try the spots on this Connecticut Ice Cream Trail first!
Joe K./Yelp
26 North Main Street, Southington, CT 06489
Sixpence Pie Company/Facebook
Please note, Sixpence Pie Company is no longer in business. These folks make the perfect buttery, flaky crust. But even better, they are more about filling than anything else so you’re getting a lot of fruit! Their minis are the perfect portion and you don’t have to share.
Google Maps
1136 New Britain Avenue, West Hartford, CT 06110
Elmwood Pastry Shop/Facebook
This pecan pie looks as though it were literally made out of gold. But guess what? It tastes even better than it looks. This family owned business has been cranking out pies since 1948 so they’re experts.
Krista C./Yelp
131 Main Street, Thomaston, CT 06787
Here’s an apple, banana cream, and chocolate cream pie just waiting to be savored. This place prides itself on making affordable pies without sacrificing on flavor. Visit often to sample their seasonal options.
35 CT-171, Woodstock, CT 06281
Soleil & Suns Bakery LLC/Facebook
Strawberry Rhubarb anyone? This full service bakery actually serves up fresh baked everything, so you can’t go wrong with a visit. Featured in Connecticut Magazine they’re a must try.
James B./Yelp
29 Route 37 Center, Sherman, CT 06784
Cesar L./Yelp
It’s so hard to choose just one of these scrumptious pies. Lucky for us, you can order by the slice because you’ll definitely want to try every one.
Anne R./Yelp
1580 Post Road, Fairfield, CT 06824
Amy T./Yelp
Not only does this place make all the classic pie flavors that you love, but they are also using cannoli in new and different ways, including in pies, tarts and cakes. Come get your little taste of Italy right here in Connecticut.
Blackberry River Baking Co/Facebook
18 Main Street, Canaan, CT 06018
Apple pies just like grandma used to make. For folks who like a crispier crust or are seeking the perfect crumble, this is the place to go. Every pie is carefully created and baked with love.
188 Leavenworth Road, Shelton, CT 06484
Oronoque Farms Gift & Bakery/Facebook
Baked to perfection, this is a great place to pick up a classic apple or a Boston Cream for a summer picnic. The braided crust is proof of the care these chefs put in to baking each pie. These pair perfectly with ice cream and are a long time fan favorite.
Bishop’s Orchards Farm Market/Facebook
1355 Boston Post Road, Guilford, CT 06437
All the fruit and cream flavors you could ever dream of, baked fresh daily and packed up for your convenience. These pies are the perfect end to an orchard visit and are guaranteed to leave your stomach (and heart) full.
Mothership Bakery & Cafe/Facebook
44 Old Ridgebury Rd, Danbury, CT 06810
This mixed berry pie is literally begging for you to eat it. And why wouldn’t you? The golden crust crumbles and then melts in your mouth and the filling is oh so sweet.
Granny’s Pie Factory/Facebook
103 School St, East Hartford, CT 06108
The delicious is hiding in the details! This place is known for its perfect outward experience, making it the go to place for pies that are both beautiful and delectable. They pride themselves on making something the whole family can enjoy together and folks just can’t get enough.
Jose C./Yelp
666 Main Avenue, Norwalk, CT 06851
Michele’s Pies/Facebook
This little shop is famous for its decadent twist on classics, like this caramel crumble covered apple. These pies have won awards in many a competition and every one is baked with love. But don’t take my word for it. Taste these pies for yourself!
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
