Pie has to be one of the most essential dishes to serve at dinners, office parties, and other get-togethers this time of year. Pumpkin, pecan, sweet potato…you name it, we love it. While homemade pies baked with a side of love are always the best, these restaurants and bakeries offer a great runner-up.
Please note: Back in Time Pie Shoppe is temporarily closed.
- Apple Annie’s Country Store, Willcox
John B./Yelp
Apple Annie’s Orchard/Facebook This well-known orchard is also famous for its fantastic country store, where you can find goods like canned jams, locally sourced honey, and freshly baked pies. You can even enjoy a slice with a hot cup of coffee in the store so you can decide how many pies to take home with you. Address: 1510 North Circle I Road, Willcox
- Back Dough, Tucson
Craig P./Yelp
Back Dough/Yelp Whether you like fruit pies, cream pies, or a savory meat pie, Back Dough offers some delicious options for all three. The pies here are made in small batches and each pie is a bit smaller than usual, making this treat feel even more special. Address: 6260 East Speedway Boulevard, Tucson
- Back In Time Pie Shoppe, Yuma
Back In Time Pie Shoppe/Facebook
Back In Time Pie Shoppe/Facebook Located in the Historic Quartermaster Depot, this dessert shop is open seasonally and gives diners a chance to enjoy a delicious meal with a side of history. Stop by for a tea party and enjoy shopping through the vintage finds when you visit. Address: 201 North 4th Avenue, Yuma
- Berry’s Pie Pantry, Prescott
DP N/Yelp
Renee S/Yelp In the mood for some comfort food in a rustic setting as the temperatures drop? You can enjoy a hearty meal followed by a slice or two of some truly amazing pie at this Prescott restaurant. 230 North Virgina Street, Prescott
- Mamma Toledo’s The Pie Hole, Phoenix
Daniel L/Yelp
Mama Toledo’s The Pie Hole/Yelp There’s nothing quite like enjoying a fresh, handmade pie and the ones at Mamma Toledo’s are simply divine. We especially love the mini pies that lets you a whole one all for yourself with a hot cup of joe. Address: 15414 North 7th Street, Phoenix
- Miss Fitz 260 Cafe, Payson
Travis T./Yelp
Deborah E./Yelp This diner sits just off the highway in Payson and in addition to serving meals that will stick to your ribs, they also have some delicious pies! This makes it a perfect road trip stop when you’re traveling between northern and southern Arizona. Address: 803 East Highway 260, Payson
- Piefection, Mesa
Piefection Pie Shop/Facebook
Piefection Pie Shop/Facebook We can’t think of a better name for a pie shop than Piefection! The pies here live up to the name and you’ll find yourself dreaming about their wide variety of pies, including their monthly specials you won’t find anywhere else. Address: 6731 East Brown Road, Mesa
- Pie Snob, Phoenix
Pie Snob/Yelp If you consider yourself a bit of a pie connoisseur, then we bet you’ll love the decadent menu featured at this bakery. Each pie is handmade, bursting with flavor, and even the crust is divine. Address: 3630 East Indian School Road, Phoenix
- Rustic Pie, Prescott
Rustic Pie Company/Facebook
Rustic Pie Company/Facebook Looking to enjoy some homestyle cooking? Rustic Pie Company serves delicious handmade pies that are perfectly sweet that you can enjoy before or after a heartwarming lunch of soup and sandwiches. Address: 802 Valley Street, Prescott
- Sugar Mama’s, Flagstaff
Sugar Mamas/Facebook
Sugar Mamas/Facebook This bakery in Flagstaff is the perfect place to pick up your favorite sweet treats, including pies. Choose a pie from their extensive menu, which includes all your favorite classic and seasonal options. Address: 2612 North Steves Boulevard, Flagstaff
Are there any other places you love to buy a slice or whole pie from? Let us know your suggestions in the comments!
John B./Yelp
Apple Annie’s Orchard/Facebook
This well-known orchard is also famous for its fantastic country store, where you can find goods like canned jams, locally sourced honey, and freshly baked pies. You can even enjoy a slice with a hot cup of coffee in the store so you can decide how many pies to take home with you. Address: 1510 North Circle I Road, Willcox
Craig P./Yelp
Back Dough/Yelp
Whether you like fruit pies, cream pies, or a savory meat pie, Back Dough offers some delicious options for all three. The pies here are made in small batches and each pie is a bit smaller than usual, making this treat feel even more special. Address: 6260 East Speedway Boulevard, Tucson
Back In Time Pie Shoppe/Facebook
Located in the Historic Quartermaster Depot, this dessert shop is open seasonally and gives diners a chance to enjoy a delicious meal with a side of history. Stop by for a tea party and enjoy shopping through the vintage finds when you visit. Address: 201 North 4th Avenue, Yuma
DP N/Yelp
Renee S/Yelp
In the mood for some comfort food in a rustic setting as the temperatures drop? You can enjoy a hearty meal followed by a slice or two of some truly amazing pie at this Prescott restaurant. 230 North Virgina Street, Prescott
Daniel L/Yelp
Mama Toledo’s The Pie Hole/Yelp
There’s nothing quite like enjoying a fresh, handmade pie and the ones at Mamma Toledo’s are simply divine. We especially love the mini pies that lets you a whole one all for yourself with a hot cup of joe. Address: 15414 North 7th Street, Phoenix
Travis T./Yelp
Deborah E./Yelp
This diner sits just off the highway in Payson and in addition to serving meals that will stick to your ribs, they also have some delicious pies! This makes it a perfect road trip stop when you’re traveling between northern and southern Arizona. Address: 803 East Highway 260, Payson
Piefection Pie Shop/Facebook
We can’t think of a better name for a pie shop than Piefection! The pies here live up to the name and you’ll find yourself dreaming about their wide variety of pies, including their monthly specials you won’t find anywhere else. Address: 6731 East Brown Road, Mesa
Pie Snob/Yelp
If you consider yourself a bit of a pie connoisseur, then we bet you’ll love the decadent menu featured at this bakery. Each pie is handmade, bursting with flavor, and even the crust is divine. Address: 3630 East Indian School Road, Phoenix
Rustic Pie Company/Facebook
Looking to enjoy some homestyle cooking? Rustic Pie Company serves delicious handmade pies that are perfectly sweet that you can enjoy before or after a heartwarming lunch of soup and sandwiches. Address: 802 Valley Street, Prescott
Sugar Mamas/Facebook
This bakery in Flagstaff is the perfect place to pick up your favorite sweet treats, including pies. Choose a pie from their extensive menu, which includes all your favorite classic and seasonal options. Address: 2612 North Steves Boulevard, Flagstaff
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
