New Jersey has hundreds (if not thousands) of terrific restaurants located all across the state. While I love sharing my favorite local eateries, it’s nearly impossible for me to be aware of every delectable dining destination between High Point and Cape May. So many magnificent destinations get missed by the media simply because we don’t know they exist.
That’s where reader recommendations come in. You can recommend any Garden State business, attraction, or noteworthy destination by filling out this nomination form. I love discovering your favorite places! Today, I’m featuring 10 restaurants submitted to Only In New Jersey, via the form or comments on articles. They are listed in no particular order.
- Pulled Fork BBQ - Long Valley
Pulled Fork BBQ/Facebook One reader described this barbecue as the best they’ve had in their life. Customers rave about the friendly service and ALL of the menu items. It seems like you can’t go wrong. The selection does vary by day but favorites include the pulled pork and chopped brisket sandwiches, cornbread pudding, and sweet tea popsicles. Enjoy a little taste of Texas!
- Alibi Beach Bar - Stanhope
Alibi Beach Bar/Facebook Readers rave about the affordable prices and atmosphere. This local favorite on Lake Lackawanna gives off some serious shore vibes. It’s relaxed and laid-back with live music, bike nights, and the breakfast Bloody Mary of your dreams, topped with two Taylor egg and cheese sliders on a freshly baked garlic knot bun.
- Sagami Japanese Restaurant - Collingswood
Sagami Japanese Restaurant/Facebook Our readers call this spot cozy and intimate with food that’s to die for. Everything is delicious and beautifully prepared. They’ve been serving up spectacular sushi since 1974 but offer so much more. Find shogayaki (broiled pork with a ginger sauce), negimako (beef scallion rolls), and other authentic dishes.
- Joe’s Bagel & Grill - Cliffwood Beach, Point Pleasant, West Long Branch, Sea Girt, Toms River, Belmar, Brick
Joe’s Bagel & Grill/Facebook This local franchise is a favorite among shore area readers. They love the sizable selection of menu options including the Texas toast grilled cheese, buffalo fried chicken sandwich, bagels, vegetarian options, and homemade buttermilk pancakes. There’s truly something for everyone.
- The Daily Bean - Vernon
The Daily Bean/Facebook According to our readers, this cafe is dog-friendly, offers gluten-free options, and is overflowing with charm. It’s described as quaint, homey, and lovely with delicious food and drinks. Try the pulled pork panini or waffles with Nutella.
- No Limits Cafe - Red Bank
No Limits Cafe/Facebook We’ve heard nothing but good things about this cafe that serves up healthy, delicious meals. They employ individuals with intellectual disabilities and our readers rave about the friendly service. Try the Jersey Tomato BLT with a twist, made with locally grown tomatoes.
- Mamma Rosa’s Restaurant - Mercerville
Mamma Rosa’s Restaurant/Facebook Only In New Jersey readers really love the tomato pies here! This restaurant also serves up authentic Italian eats in a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere.
- The Boathouse - Newton
The Boathouse/Facebook This charmer on Swartswood Lake has readers gushing about the gorgeous setting and fabulous food. Serving lunch, dinner, and cocktails, this restaurant is made for outdoor dining. Try the grilled filet mignon topped with a garlic bacon demi glaze or the turkey melt on a pretzel bun with raspberry aioli, arugula, and brie.
- Campus Sub Shop II - Springfield
Campus Sub Shop II/Facebook If you’re looking for delicious deli and breakfast sandwiches near Springfield, readers say this is the spot. They have dozens of options to choose from…where to begin. The Italian Cheeseburger is topped with peppers, onions, potatoes, mustard, and ketchup. Yum!
- Avellino’s Pizzeria & Sports Bar - Dunellen
Google Maps According to our readers, they treat customers like family and have some of the best food around. Try the pizza sub, pizza burger, pizza steak, or famous $7 pizzas (Monday-Wednesday). They’ve also got seafood, sausage & peppers, penne a la rabiata, and zeppoles.
Call before heading out to any of these eateries – some require reservations, others only offer take-out or delivery. Check first as the situation is continually evolving. Don’t see anything near you on this list? That’s probably because nothing in your area was nominated. Don’t despair; share your favorite eateries with us for part two.
Pulled Fork BBQ/Facebook
One reader described this barbecue as the best they’ve had in their life. Customers rave about the friendly service and ALL of the menu items. It seems like you can’t go wrong. The selection does vary by day but favorites include the pulled pork and chopped brisket sandwiches, cornbread pudding, and sweet tea popsicles. Enjoy a little taste of Texas!
Alibi Beach Bar/Facebook
Readers rave about the affordable prices and atmosphere. This local favorite on Lake Lackawanna gives off some serious shore vibes. It’s relaxed and laid-back with live music, bike nights, and the breakfast Bloody Mary of your dreams, topped with two Taylor egg and cheese sliders on a freshly baked garlic knot bun.
Sagami Japanese Restaurant/Facebook
Our readers call this spot cozy and intimate with food that’s to die for. Everything is delicious and beautifully prepared. They’ve been serving up spectacular sushi since 1974 but offer so much more. Find shogayaki (broiled pork with a ginger sauce), negimako (beef scallion rolls), and other authentic dishes.
Joe’s Bagel & Grill/Facebook
This local franchise is a favorite among shore area readers. They love the sizable selection of menu options including the Texas toast grilled cheese, buffalo fried chicken sandwich, bagels, vegetarian options, and homemade buttermilk pancakes. There’s truly something for everyone.
The Daily Bean/Facebook
According to our readers, this cafe is dog-friendly, offers gluten-free options, and is overflowing with charm. It’s described as quaint, homey, and lovely with delicious food and drinks. Try the pulled pork panini or waffles with Nutella.
No Limits Cafe/Facebook
We’ve heard nothing but good things about this cafe that serves up healthy, delicious meals. They employ individuals with intellectual disabilities and our readers rave about the friendly service. Try the Jersey Tomato BLT with a twist, made with locally grown tomatoes.
Mamma Rosa’s Restaurant/Facebook
Only In New Jersey readers really love the tomato pies here! This restaurant also serves up authentic Italian eats in a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere.
The Boathouse/Facebook
This charmer on Swartswood Lake has readers gushing about the gorgeous setting and fabulous food. Serving lunch, dinner, and cocktails, this restaurant is made for outdoor dining. Try the grilled filet mignon topped with a garlic bacon demi glaze or the turkey melt on a pretzel bun with raspberry aioli, arugula, and brie.
Campus Sub Shop II/Facebook
If you’re looking for delicious deli and breakfast sandwiches near Springfield, readers say this is the spot. They have dozens of options to choose from…where to begin. The Italian Cheeseburger is topped with peppers, onions, potatoes, mustard, and ketchup. Yum!
Google Maps
According to our readers, they treat customers like family and have some of the best food around. Try the pizza sub, pizza burger, pizza steak, or famous $7 pizzas (Monday-Wednesday). They’ve also got seafood, sausage & peppers, penne a la rabiata, and zeppoles.
OnlyInYourState may earn compensation through affiliate links in this article.
Address: 38 E Mill Rd, Long Valley, NJ 07853, USAAddress: 172 Lackawanna Dr, Stanhope, NJ 07874, USAAddress: 37 Crescent Blvd, Collingswood, NJ 08108, USAAddress: 801 Main St, Belmar, NJ 07719, USAAddress: 516 Co Rd 515, Vernon Township, NJ 07462, USAAddress: 418 NJ-35, Red Bank, NJ 07701, USAAddress: 572 Klockner Rd, Hamilton Township, NJ 08619, USAAddress: 1040 Co Rd 521, Swartswood, NJ 07877, USAAddress: 234 Morris Ave, Springfield Township, NJ 07081, USAAddress: 625 Bound Brook Rd, Dunellen, NJ 08812, USA
